Why vague job ads get fewer applicants
A new study has a simple finding: job ads that lean on personality traits and office perks get fewer applicants than ads that spell out what the work actually is. That's according to research covered by HR Dive. No fireworks, no surprise twist, just a quiet confirmation of something most job seekers already feel in their gut.
You've seen the type of ad this is about. "We're looking for a team player with a positive attitude in a fast-paced environment." Free coffee. Table tennis. A photo of people laughing around a laptop. None of it tells you what you'd actually do on a Tuesday afternoon.
That's the problem. A job ad is supposed to answer one question: is this work I can do and want to do? Personality traits don't answer that. Neither does the coffee machine. What does answer it is the task list, the tools you'd use, the team you'd report to, and what a normal day looks like.
The study suggests people notice the gap. When a posting is vague, fewer people apply. Not because the job sounds bad, but because nobody can picture themselves doing it. You can't picture yourself being a "team player". You can picture yourself writing code in Python, answering forty calls a day, or driving a forklift in a warehouse.
There's a reason so many ads end up vague anyway. Sometimes the role isn't fully defined yet, so the person writing it fills the gaps with general enthusiasm instead of specifics. Sometimes it's an attempt to appeal to as many people as possible, which usually backfires and appeals to no one. And sometimes it's simply easier to write "dynamic" than to sit down and list the actual requirements.
For job seekers, this is worth remembering the next time you scroll past an ad that's all adjectives and no detail. It's not always a red flag, but it's often a sign that the employer hasn't thought the role through, or is leaving out something less attractive, like the salary, the hours, or the amount of overtime.
For employers, the fix is less exciting than it sounds: write down what the person will actually do. Tools, tasks, team, reporting line. It takes longer than typing "energetic self-starter wanted" but it saves time later, because the people who do apply already know what they're signing up for. Fewer wrong-fit applications, less time wasted on interviews that go nowhere.
None of this is complicated. It's also not new advice, which is part of what makes the finding interesting: plenty of employers already know specific job ads work better, and still write vague ones out of habit. At Will Werk we try to push the other way, clear tasks, clear requirements, and a salary indication where we have one. It's not glamorous. It just gets the right people to apply.
← More from the blog